About Us
Large Inventory
Personalized Service
Competitive Pricing
We have a large inventory of both guns and ammo. In addition, we have access to a large network to locate and deliver any firearm you maybe looking for. We can order just about any firearm available today and have it in house within 72 hours. Contact us to buy, sell, or trade today!
Competitive Pricing
Personalized Service
Competitive Pricing
We are able to provide competitive pricing based on our size, buying power, and large network of distributors.
Personalized Service
Personalized Service
Personalized Service
We are able to provide you with personalized service. Just give us a call or send us an email and we are ready to assist.
join our mailing list
Sign up to hear from us about new inventory, specials, sales, and events.
Tour our Shop
Step inside our shop and explore our space through this virtual tour!
Products and services
Modern New & Used Guns
We have a large inventory of all types of guns to meet you needs. We have everything from AR-15s to Hunting Rifles and Shotguns to Handguns to Carbines. We have a wide range of suppliers and sources that can deliver whatever we do not have in stock that you want! We Buy, Sell, or Trade all types of guns. We can provide free appraisals and consignment services.
Ammo & Accessories
We have both ammo and accessories. Everything from speed loaders to magazines, and more. All in stock and available.
FFL Transfer Services
We are happy to accept Firearms and Ammunition Transfers. Please reach out to us to discuss both pricing and the process.
Antique & Vintage Firearms
From bolt actions to lever action repeating rifles, our collection of antique firearms represents the expansive number of guns that come from a bygone era. Our collection includes early American sporting firearms, military firearms, as well as everyday hunting rifles and the great handguns of the day. We are constantly updating our inventory of modern handguns & long guns, antique pistols &, rifles, collectible guns, ammunition and related firearm products five days a week here at our shop. Manufacturers include Henry, Sharps, Spencer, Colt, Marlin, Winchester, Remington and more!
Gun Appraisals & Estate Services
We are a full service estate consulting and appraisal service, with a primary focus on the highly specialized area of guns. We conduct appraisals for auctions and personal collections, taking into account type, rarity, provenance, condition, and completeness of the guns as well as the current market. If you are interested in selling a gun or a whole collection, we can sell them for you under our GunBroker page. Contact us to discuss your options.
Gun Consignments
We accept firearms and unique accessories to sell under our consignment program.
Consignment is a good way to liquidate unwanted or unneeded firearms from your home, make some extra room in your safe or simply to generate some capital to purchase that new firearm.
Consignment starts with coming to our store where your firearm is inspected and valued for sale. Once accepted into our inventory, your firearm is displayed and marketed to obtain you a fair market value for the firearm(s) as quickly as possible.
Just Some of the Brands We Have In Stock
ebay store
GUNS International Store
Contact Us
If you have questions about our products and services, feel free to send us a message. We promise will get back to you as soon as possible. Thank You!
Fagans Firearms, LLC
15849 New York Highway 23, Davenport, New York 13750, United States
(Convenient customer parking is available at the rear of our store) 607-278-4059 (call) 914-400-9207 (text / call) fagansfirearms@aol.com (email)
Store Hours
Monday: 10am - 5pm
Tuesday: 10am - 5pm
Wednesday: By Appointment
Thursday: 10am - 5pm
Friday: 10am - 5pm
Saturday: 9am - 5pm
Sunday: By Appointment
For an Appointment, please call.
Our Partners
Copyright © 2025 Fagans Firearms - All Rights Reserved.
This website uses cookies.
We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.